Nobody goes further to find great wines. Explore our huge range with wine delivery across New Zealand.

  • Home
  • All wines
  • Critics Choice Mixed Dozen

Critics Choice Mixed Dozen

Save up to $93 on a dozen delicious reds and whites highly rated by writers and show judges. You’ll see a stream of high point scores, Gold medals and better, all assuring your tastebuds will be fully satisfied.

In white, look forward to the considerable charms of 92pt Clare Valley Riesling from Moonlake, and 93pt Verdelho from highly rated Angullong estate in the region of Orange in Australia’s New South Wales. Their Verdelho is “Delicately fragrant and enticing…” and “Bright and lively with a persistent, exuberant finish. 93pts” (Sam Kim, Wine Orbit). If Sauvignon is your go-to variety you have a couple of real delights in store. Angaston Rd Growers’ Sauvignon comes from vineyards in Coonawarra. This fine example boasts TWO Gold medals and scores of 96pts and 92pts for its “bright fruit intensity combined with vibrant acidity…” making it “instantly appealing” (Sam Kim, Wine Orbit). Moss Brothers, from Western Australia, offer their 93pt classic Margaret River blend of Sauvignon and Semillon, which here delivers a “fabulously aromatic bouquet” and “excellent vibrancy and exuberance” (Sam Kim, Wine Orbit). 90pt Il Papavero Pinot Grigio is a “Juicy and vibrant crowd-pleaser with Italian charm. Perfect for long summer nights” (Sally Duncan), while Sam Trimboli enjoys exploring his Italian heritage – his 91pt Pecorino, a good example. In red, enjoy mighty 95pt two-Gold Vinha do Fava Touriga Nacional, which has, in 9 vintages notched up 34 Golds (Grand Golds and Double Golds included), plus a Trophy. Plus, there’s 92pt Il Papavero, a silky charmer made using four varieties from top-performing regions. Italy in a bottle! From Australia, Lehmann’s 94pt Pastor’s Son Shiraz is “pure Barossa brilliance in a glass” (Sally Duncan), Sevenhill’s 94pt “refined Clare Valley Cabernet… poised and focussed” (Ray Jordan); 92pt, Gold-medal Vin’atus Tempranillo Graciano from RedHeads, and Sam Trimboli’s Trophy, Top Gold, 96pt triple-whammy combo of Shiraz Durif Grenache, which rounds the case off in style!

3.9 Average bottle rating
Critics Choice Mixed Dozen
$263.88$351.00
SAVE $87.12
1 case (12 bottles) - $21.99 per bottle
100% Money-back Guarantee
Free shipping on orders over $395

Case Contents

Il Papavero 2024

Regular price: $28 per bottle
Find out why silky, Italian charmer, Il Papavero is our most reordered red of all time!
  • Red - Medium Bodied
  • ItalyItaly
92

Wine Details

  • Red blend
  • 7.40625 Units
  • Vegan
  • 12.5% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 31 December 2027
  • Packaging Pioneer
Il Papavero

Il Papavero Pinot Grigio 2024

Regular price: $26 per bottle
Brilliant Pinot Grigio with top marks for character, quality and value. Creamy and refreshing too.
90

Wine Details

Il Papavero Pinot Grigio
A generous top-estate exclusive 94pt Barossa Shiraz,with a great back story and Gold-medal history!
94

Wine Details

  • Shiraz
  • 8.295 Units
  • 14% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 04 January 2035
Peter Lehmann The Pastor's Son Barossa Shiraz

Moonlake Clare Valley Riesling 2024

Regular price: $28 per bottle
92pt latest release of this hauntingly popular Clare Valley Riesling.
92
90

Wine Details

  • Riesling
  • 6.5175 Units
  • 11% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • 31 December 2026
Moonlake Clare Valley Riesling

RedHeads Vin’atus 2022

Regular price: $35 per bottle
The grapes may be Spanish starlets, but the wine is 100% pure Aussie
Gold
92

Wine Details

RedHeads Vin’atus

Vinha do Fava Touriga Nacional 2023

Regular price: $30 per bottle
Portugal’s pride and joy grape, barrel-aged to perfection in this 2 x Gold, 95pt luscious big red.
Gold
95
Gold

Wine Details

Vinha do Fava Touriga Nacional
A 94pt single vineyard Cabernet from Australia's Clare Valley – "poised and focussed" (WinePilot).
91
94

Wine Details

Sevenhill Cellars Estate Grown Inigo Clare Valley Cabernet Sauvignon
Gold-medal, 96pt, beautifully balanced Sauvignon from Australia's Coonawarra.
92
Gold
Gold
96

Wine Details

Angaston Road Growers Rae Clark Coonawarra Sauvignon Blanc

Moss Brothers Sauvignon Blanc Semillon 2023

Regular price: $35 per bottle
A classic 93pt SBS from Western Australia's celebrated Margaret River region.
91
93

Wine Details

Moss Brothers Sauvignon Blanc Semillon
Trophy-winning debut of a triple whammy Aussie red from the astonishing Sam Trimboli.
Top Gold
96
Best Riverina Dry Red

Wine Details

Sam Trimboli Bin Select Shiraz Durif Grenache

Angullong Orange Verdelho 2023

Regular price: $28 per bottle
Enjoy a tropical taste of Australia’s Orange region with this "fragrant and enticing" 93pt Verdelho.
93

Wine Details

  • Verdelho
  • 7.99875 Units
  • Vegan
  • 13.5% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 31 December 2026
Angullong Orange Verdelho

Trimboli Saverio Adelaide Pecorino 2025

Regular price: $29 per bottle
Sam Trimboli brings you yet another refreshing treat inspired by his Italian heritage.
91

Wine Details

  • Pecorino
  • 7.11 Units
  • Vegan
  • 12% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 08 January 2027
Trimboli Saverio Adelaide Pecorino
100% Money-Back Guarantee Icon

100% MONEY-BACK

Guarantee

Award-winning wine & customer service icon

AWARD-WINNING

Wine & customer service